I am one of those who harshly criticized a newcomer’s OC-turned-into-fluffy.
I did so because it conflicted not only with the “widespread” definition of fluffy (using this term loosely, as there’s no real set-in-stone true fluffy, although most renditions usually share the same common tropes, like being rather dull-minded, physically weak, loving spaghetti more than anything, yadda yadda) but also because said character radiated major “bad trope juju”.
With that being said, the opinion of a random internet jackass called A-S (dude couldn’t even be arsed to write a real name) shouldn’t be the end of all things. Heed my word and cut down on the overall “edgy-ness” by reducing the character’s skillset to something a “general” fluffy might have (even something a bit more, a pit-fighter fluffy may indeed be able to pick on other fluffies or small critters, or at least have human intervention be responsible for their teeth being filed into being sharper, rather than them going Rambo mode and doing it themselves against a rock, somehow). Or disregard it entirely and go right on. It’s not a big deal.
The part that really bothers me, however is not edgy OCs that might make for interesting characters with just a wee bit of polishing around the edges (pun intended), it’s when artists introduce their own species of “fluffies”, who end up taking the spotlight instead of well, the actual fluffies.
I don’t want to call out specific people, especially since it’s people whose stories I’ve been reading and have enjoyed a good chunk of.
However, I can think of no better example right now.
Oversized, “fluffy-fied” viruses. The stories involving them rotate around these bundles of love and deadly goo, relegating fluffies to side characters at best, background scenery only there to be infected, go SCREEE and allow the sentient viruses to replicate.
At least in my head, fluffies should be the focus of a fluffy story on fluffycommunity.
Simply because said viruses talk like fluffies and are just as innocently dumb, it doesn’t make them fluffies.
Just my 2 cents.