G.O.A.T. Discussion 2025

To celebrate the return of several fuck-balls, big-dick-swinging, amazing, talented creators like @Swift and @Dragonixa and so many others…

I gotta know.

What do you think is the perfect fluffy pony story? Text or image, what hits all the right notes, #for you personally? #

the perfect world building, illustrations, compelling stories, emotional impact, or just plain fun.

We can tell from site metrics that fucking legends like @NekuChan’s The path to poopie paradise (By: NekuChan) and @KerosineCannibal NO MIWKIES part 1 (artist KerosineCannibal–author Foalout4) @Bad_Roomie Mumma? Miwkies? (Bad_Roomie) get the most traffic, but we can’t measure how much a story impacts you based on numbers.

In the spirit of more flies with honey, maybe if we make a big showing of how much our work as creators is appreciated we can get more artists to come back and create again.

What is your personal Greatest of All Time?

11 Likes

Cherish the Moment (Ace)

This is perfect. This is a quintessential fluffy pony story for me. It hits all the right notes and @Ace always immerses his reader entirely and you feel like not only is this real, you feel like you’re part of the family.

7 Likes

Honestly, I always loved the most dark and fucked up stuff, like by @Turboencabulator :heart: His Peter story never left my mind :smiley:

2 Likes

Josef Finds A Fluffy Ch.1 [By BFM101] is a lot to chew on, it’s a dense, lore heavy read that when put through a text to speech reader was ##6## hours of content. And I missed like half just the Josef stories, not even to the harknsesses or Jonathan yet.

But it is perfect. When I think of fluffies this is what I think of.

@BFM101 is my comfort read. Whenever I get sick I need hot curry and to curl up in the bleak nightmare he created. It’s a ritual now.

Edit: there’s no way to casually enjoy 12 plus hours of content. Of course all of bfm’s fans are fanatical and nuttier than squirrel turds.

3 Likes

Hands down, the goat @SHADOWSTEIN with Will To Live. Absolute cinema in there.

2 Likes

@Poopiest_of_bebbehs is a whore for feedback, criticism gives him a turgid nunu, but honestly,

Bonnie VS: The Aristocrats PART:1 (Poopiest_of_bebbehs)

Is perfect. No notes.

Dude came into the community swinging for the fences.

5 Likes

I’m not sure how to feel about this compliment, or the type of reader my works seem to attract.

Anyway, I’ve said it before but Rosemary by Jim Profit stands out the best Fluffy story in my eyes. It’s got a perfect blend of hugbox cuteness, moronbox simplicity, and the unfortunately cruelty that comes from trying to do the right thing with a creature that cannot understand it’s own wants.

4 Likes

Anything by @Ace

3 Likes

@Ace, @PeppermintParchment, and @Maple all currently write stories that hit what I call ‘the fluffy note’

If we’re talking old stuff, Millie may be one of the most influencial fluffy stories for me

8 Likes

Pixie and Donna and Daddy’s Mad by @Julie really hit me in the feels

5 Likes

Federal

Honestly. Sobbing. It’s beautiful. It’s tender. It’s REAL. Perfect

5 Likes

I asked about what kind of content people would want to see the most some time ago and I didn’t receive any clear answers, hope this thread goes better

1 Like

‘The Groomer’ series by @AliceFluff is pretty stinking good.

Just about (anything) from @Maple

‘Fat Shaming’ by @PeppermintParchment has always been a fav

‘Scooter Goes Cyberbullying’ by @ezpete

‘It Beats Going Home’ by @Virgil

Anything Glimmer related but ‘Glimmer Side Story #:1 The Last Hit’ by @ambitiousleather8309 is short, poignant, and the accompanying art is wonderful

7 Likes

One of the things I love the most is fluffies growing into things, like if you would leave a foal in a can in the can for too long and it would grow into the shape of the can
Though I’m not sure if it’s wise for me to draw that kind of stuff anymore do to past happenings

1 Like

Stop, I’m blushing.

2 Likes

There’s such a wide spectrum that it’s hard for me to pinpoint a single work or author. I personally enjoy Wangew Wick’s characterization of the individuals in his stories, Hornlarry’s ambition to add a metaphysical element to Fluffies, as well as MadMartigan’s unhinged and unrelenting abuse.

2 Likes

How about quit whining and get back to doing what the Ed do best:

Magnum opus level shit here. As far as I’m concerned the only fluffy creator on YouTube.

1 Like

Text posts for me! Like remember when Ace did those fluffy ecosystems? Those were my favs!! We lack in neutral/abuse stories lately and that spice you be lovely to see <33

2 Likes

McGee told me to tell you he wants more fluffy sex

3 Likes

@Stwumpo has so many amazing stories in my opinion: Honest Mistake, Running to Sweet Nerissa, and my personal favourite: Six One, Half a Dozen The Other.

4 Likes